Sod vs Artificial Turf: Which Is The Better Option?

Last Updated on November 11, 2024 by ReTurf

When you’re planning an outdoor space—whether it’s your backyard, a sports field, or a playground—the choice of ground cover isn’t just a detail—it’s a decision that shapes how that space feels, how it looks day in and day out, and how much time, money, and energy it will require from you over the years.

Two main options stand out: artificial turf and natural grass sod. They’re two sides of the landscaping coin, really—one polished and precise, the other alive and unpredictable.

Artificial turf has a reputation for durability and near-effortless upkeep. It can be ideal if you’re tired of weekly lawn care or live in a place where water is more precious than gold. On the flip side, there’s just something about natural grass that tugs at our nostalgia, in spite of the large amount of maintenance, time, and resources it often requires to keep up.

Sod and turf both have their pros and cons—but the answer to “which is better?” all depends on what your space needs.

Before We Get Started: Is There a “Right” Answer?

When it comes to outdoor spaces, it’s easy to fall into the same tired discussions about artificial turf versus natural grass sod. Most articles tend to follow a familiar script—pros, cons, cost breakdowns—and while those details are important, they don’t always address the deeper, more strategic decision-making that comes into play.

The truth is, your choice here isn’t just about aesthetics or how much maintenance you’re willing to take on—it’s also about how each option aligns with your long-term goals for the space and how you intend to use it.

Will water restrictions become an issue, or do you live in an area with plenty of rain?

Is this for a quiet backyard where you’ll be entertaining a handful of guests a few times a year? Or do you have a busy home with kids, pets, and lots of outdoor parties and recreation, where the lawn sees more traffic than a weekend sports field?

In the latter case, natural grass might struggle to keep up, turning into patchy, muddy messes after every rainy day or rough game of tag.

These are the kind of practical questions that matter, and while we’ll certainly cover all the basics like cost and upkeep, let’s not forget that the choice between turf and sod is as much about the lifestyle and functionality you’re aiming for as it is about what looks good “on paper.”

So no, there’s no universally “correct” answer for every property owner in America—just the right choice for your specific needs and priorities. And that’s the kind of decision worth spending a little extra time thinking about.

Artificial Turf: What You Need to Know

Artificial turf has come a long way. Originally designed for sports fields, it’s now used in all kinds of outdoor spaces—lawns, parks, even commercial landscapes. It’s made of synthetic fibers meant to look like grass, but with less work. Over the years, the materials used have gotten softer, more durable, and much more realistic looking.

Much of the artificial turf you find for sale today is a far cry from the hard stuff they rolled out in the ’60s. These days, it’s softer, more resilient, and works in all kinds of weather. That’s why it’s such a popular choice for areas where real grass can’t hold up.

That being said, not all artificial turf is manufacturerd to the same level of quality. Sure, a lot of what’s available today is miles ahead of the stiff, unnaturally-green stuff that came out during the Space Race, but there are still some lower-quality options out there—think the cheap rolls of turf you might find at your local big-box store. These cheaper versions can still feel a bit rough, might not hold up as well over time, and could end up looking worn or faded much sooner than you’d like.

When you’re looking at high-quality turf, especially the kind used for professional landscapes or sports fields, there’s really nothing that beats it. The texture, durability, and appearance are so much better that it can easily pass for real grass, without the constant maintenance.

It’s also softer, holds up in tough weather, and gives you that consistent, green look year-round. So while turf has come a long way, you still get what you pay for when it comes to quality.

Why Artificial Turf?

• Durability is one of its biggest selling points. It handles heavy foot traffic and tough weather without turning into a muddy mess or dying off in patches. That makes it ideal for playgrounds, fields, or any spot that gets a lot of use.
• Low maintenance is another big plus. You won’t need to water it, mow it, or worry about fertilizing. No need for sprinklers or gas-powered lawnmowers either. Less water use and fewer chemicals make it an environmentally sound option, too. Plus, it stays green year-round, no matter what the weather’s like.

Tip: If you choose used artificial turf, like the kind offered by ReTurf, you’re also making a more sustainable choice by repurposing high-quality turf from places like stadiums. It’s a win-win—you get the look and feel of new turf without the environmental cost of producing more plastic.

What to Consider with Artificial Turf

There are a few things to keep in mind with synthetic grass:

• Heat retention can be an issue—turf can get warm under direct sun, which might make it uncomfortable to walk on barefoot during hot days. If you’re in a particularly sunny, hot area, this is something to consider. That said, artificial turf lawns are still a common solution in hot, dry climates where water conservation is important.
• Turf does typically have a higher upfront cost compared to sod and grass. As this is a one time cost, it’s important to factor in that over time, the savings on maintenance that is required for living grass lawns—like water, fertilizer, and lawn care equipment/services—can make up for that initial investment.
• As to the environmental impact, while turf does help conserve water and reduce the need for fertilizers or pesticides, much of it is still made of plastic. That does raise some concerns about how it’s produced and disposed of. However, opting for used turf or 100% recyclable artificial turf, like what ReTurf offers, can help minimize some of these issues by recycling and/or reusing material.

Natural Grass: What to Expect

Organic sod with natural grass is a classic choice. It’s simply rolls of grass that can be transplanted into your yard or field, ready to start rooting into the soil and growing as soon as it’s laid down.

This option has been used for centuries to establish grassy areas (such as residential lawns) and repair damaged land.

After being “installed,” it needs quite a bit of care to keep it alive and looking healthy—watering, mowing, fertilizing, weeding, and maybe some pest control for bugs and moles/voles/gophers—but if done correctly and consistently, those efforts can pay off with a healthy, green lawn.

Why Go with Natural Grass & Sod?

There can be an appeal to the natural look it provides. When first installed, it offers a uniform, green landscape that many homeowners appreciate for traditional outdoor spaces. Sod and grass can ultimately create an appearance that blends with the surroundings.

Natural grass sod does come with some environmental benefits. It can help prevent soil erosion, contribute to soil health, and play a role in absorbing carbon dioxide while releasing oxygen. Additionally, it aids in water filtration by reducing runoff. A well-maintained sod lawn can support various forms of wildlife, adding to the ecosystem’s diversity.

The Drawbacks of Sod

The initial appeal of natural grass sod lies in the classic look it provides. When first installed, it can create a uniform, green landscape that many homeowners appreciate for traditional outdoor spaces. However, this initial perfection can be fleeting.

Maintaining that cohesive appearance often requires significant time and effort, as natural grass is subject to weather conditions, soil quality, and wear and tear. So, while sod can offer an authentic touch that integrates seamlessly with the environment, keeping it lush and healthy over time may present challenges:

Maintenance is a big one. Sod requires regular watering, especially in the early stages when the roots are establishing. Then, there’s mowing, fertilizing, and pest control to keep it healthy. Over time, it can get expensive and labor-intensive, especially if you have a large area to manage.

Another issue is timing. Organic sod needs to be installed in the right season—usually spring or fall—when the weather isn’t too harsh. Lay it down outside of these windows, and you risk poor root development, which leads to more work down the line.

Lastly, sod is vulnerable to pests and diseases. Bugs like grubs or beetles can ruin your lawn, and fungal infections can creep in, requiring regular monitoring and possibly the use of pesticides.

Water consumption can be significant. Sod needs regular watering, especially in hot or dry climates. If you live somewhere prone to drought or have water restrictions, this can become a real issue—not to mention an added cost on your water bill.

Soil preparation is critical before laying sod. You’ll need to properly grade, fertilize, and possibly even aerate the soil to make sure the roots take hold. If this step isn’t done well, the sod may not establish properly, leading to patchy grass and more maintenance down the road.

Wear and tear can also be a problem. High-traffic areas can wear out quickly, leaving bare patches that need repair or replacement. This means ongoing upkeep if your lawn sees a lot of foot traffic or if it’s used for recreation or sports (or kids or pets with a lot of energy!).

Lastly, shade tolerance can be an issue. While some types of sod are more shade-tolerant than others, grass typically needs sunlight to thrive. If you’ve got a lot of trees or shaded areas, you may end up with thin or dying patches of grass.

Artificial Turf vs. Natural Grass: What’s the Better Choice?

So, how do these two stack up against each other?

• Cost: Artificial turf costs more upfront but saves you in the long run by cutting down on water, mowing, and fertilizers. Sod is cheaper at the start, but the maintenance costs add up over time.
• Maintenance: Turf wins for low maintenance. No mowing, watering, or fertilizing—just a bit of cleaning here and there. Natural grass and sod? They need constant care, especially in hot or dry climates.
• Environmental Impact: Sod helps the environment by filtering water, producing oxygen, and supporting biodiversity. Artificial turf cuts down on water and chemicals but is still made from plastic. Reused turf, like what ReTurf offers, is a more eco-friendly choice for those who prefer artificial.
• Durability: Turf is your go-to if you’ve got heavy foot traffic or a harsh climate. Sod looks and feels great but can get worn out in high-use areas.
• Aesthetic: If you want that natural, classic lawn look, nothing beats real grass. But if you’re after a pristine, low-maintenance space that stays green year-round, turf is hard to beat.

So, who’s the winner? It depends on what you’re after. If you’re looking for something low maintenance, durable, and can stomach the upfront cost, artificial turf might be the way to go. If you just love the idea of real grass, and don’t mind the effort to keep it up, sod is still a classic choice.

While artificial turf doesn’t offer the same natural ecosystem benefits as sod, modern advancements have made it more realistic and eco-friendly than earlier versions. It can also be more durable in high-traffic areas, where natural grass might struggle to maintain its condition.

At the end of the day, both options can lay the groundwork (pun intended) for some pretty fantastic-looking outdoor spaces—it’s just picking the one that fits your lifestyle and what you’re willing to maintain over time.

Making the Right Choice for Your Space

When it comes down to it, the decision between artificial turf and natural grass sod depends on what works best for your specific needs. For example:

• Consider your climate. In regions where water is scarce and droughts are a common concern, the practicality of artificial turf becomes evident. It requires no watering, making it a viable option for homeowners who want a green outdoor space without the added burden of hefty water bills or strained water resources.

• Think about how you’ll use the space. Areas that see frequent use—whether from kids running around, pets playing, or even neighborhood sports games—can benefit from the resilience of artificial turf. Turf can stand up to heavy foot traffic without turning into a patchy or muddy mess, maintaining its appearance with minimal effort.

• For those who prefer a natural, less-uniform look, sod may provide the traditional look and feel that some prefer.

Personal preferences always come into play, and they can be tough to shake. Some people are set on the idea of real grass, and embrace the routines that come with it—mowing, watering, dealing with occasional weeds, and navigating the occasional bout of fungus or pests. They love the idea of a natural lawn, even if it means much more work in the long run.

Other homeowners would rather skip lawn upkeep altogether—and wouldn’t touch a lawnmower if you paid them. So for those who see mowing, fertilizing, and watering as nuisances that eat up precious free time on the weekends, artificial turf can present as an attractive, low-maintenance solution. The idea of a pristine lawn that stays green throughout the year, without the usual fuss, can indeed be very appealing.

In the end, both sod and artificial turf have their benefits. The right choice is the one that suits your priorities, your willingness to manage upkeep, and the vision you have for your space.

The Bottom Line: Which is Better for You?

If you’re still debating between artificial turf and natural grass, you’re not alone. It’s not always an easy decision, and it really comes down to what you’re willing to live with. If you prefer a yard that stays looking great without needing constant attention, artificial turf could feel like a practical solution. No mowing, no watering—just install it and enjoy. Maintenance is as simple as an occasional rinse with the hose.

Think about that compared to the upkeep required for natural grass: regular mowing, scheduled watering, applying fertilizers, and tackling weeds and pests. In areas with water restrictions or tough weather conditions, keeping grass lush and healthy can become a real commitment. That’s a lot of weekends spent managing your lawn’s needs. Once artificial turf is installed, though, it’s more or less on autopilot.

Of course, some people can’t quite give up the feel and charm of real grass. There’s a certain appeal to it, even if it means you’re dealing with weeds or lugging out the hose and lawn products. Choosing between turf and grass is about how you want to spend your time—do you envision yourself tending and nurturing a lawn, or would you rather have a space that stays picture-perfect with minimal effort?

At the end of the day, it’s less about which option is objectively “better” and more about which fits your lifestyle. Both artificial turf and natural grass can create a beautiful yard. The real question is how much time, energy, or money you’re willing to commit.

If artificial turf seems like it might be the better choice for you—especially used or new, eco-friendly,  100% recyclable artificial turf, check out ReTurf for more information. It’s a way to get the best of both worlds: convenience and sustainability.

The Artificial Turf Experts

At ReTurf, we’re dedicated to making your artificial turf project a complete success. Whether you’re looking for the right product, professional installation services, step-by-step DIY guidance, or expert advice on design and maintenance, our team is here to support you. Our experienced team of artificial turf experts are committed to assisting you through every stage of your project.

Have questions or ready to start? Reach out to us at (828) 518-5787 or send us an email to connect with a member of our team. We’re here to make sure your turf installation is smooth and hassle-free from start to finish. Let’s get your project rolling!